Tuesday, August 14, 2018

Opuscula

Thoughts
On selihot
On the Web

ACCORDING TO MOST AUTHORITIES, parts of selihot must be omitted when said sans a minyan.

* All the Aramaic is skipped.

* Each kaddish is skipped.

* Each of the 13 attributes of HaShem (ויעבר) are skipped.

Each of the above requires a minyan.

THANKS TO THE INTERNET, there may be a way to have a “virtual” minyan.

According to Rabbi Yaacov Laredo (https://www.mybnai.com/clergy.html) of the B'nai Sephardim Synagogue in Hollywood FL, it may be possible to participate in a virtual minyan and to recite all of the sections skipped when there is no minyan.

R. Laredo makes it clear that this applies ONLY to selihot. It does not apply to any other service.

The virtual minyan must be in real time; more than a few seconds latency – delay in transmitting sound from Point A to Point B – and the virtual minyan is not a minyan.

However, he cited several popular applications that meet the “real time” requirement; included are WhatsApp, Facetime, and similar. Perhaps Google’s Hangouts and Microsoft’s Skype also qualify providing there is a fast internet service provider (ISP).

OK – R. Laredo stopped here.

I got to thinking.

If I am too lazy to drag myself out of bed in time for a 6 a.m. (or earlier) selihot minyan, maybe I could “sleep in” and catch a minyan in the Central time zone.

That’s cheating since (Sefardi) selihot’s opening words are “קמתי באשמורת“ – roughly “I got up during the night watch” which of course a Central time zone minyan belies that statement.

According to My Zmanim (https://www.myzmanim.com), I’m “good” as long as I can complete reciting the שמע on or before 9:32 a.m. (That’s the last time for the shema according to Gra & Baal HaTanya for Hollywood FL on August 14, 2018. Times change daily.) Of course, praying sans a minyan means no kaddish and no repetition of the Ahmedah, but late risers might find a late starting minyan that still will “beat the shema clock.” (There are a couple of minyans that start at 8 a.m.; neither congregation is Sefardi or Mizrachi, so selihot during Elul are not an issue.)

To their credit, there is a minyan plus at 6 a.m. at B’nai Sephardim and Tiferet Rafael (http://tiferetrafael.org/); Nahar Shalom (http://naharshalom.com/), also in Hollywood, starts selihot before 5:30 and also manages a minyan.

PLAGIARISM is the act of appropriating the literary composition of another, or parts or passages of his writings, or the ideas or language of the same, and passing them off as the product of one’s own mind.

Truth is an absolute defense to defamation. Defamation is a false statement of fact. If the statement was accurate, then by definition it wasn’t defamatory.

Comments on Selihot via the web